Chris's Morgan's SLiMP3 brief review
I just received my SLiMP3 from Slim Devices Inc.
It's a purpose built mp3 playback component which relies on
streamed data from a server over ethernet. Go here to read about the product
in the words of the vendor.
What follows is my own personal view :
- Price. The price is ok but not super-cheap, however since this
model is hand-assembled, there's a certain neato factor to it that
made me more than happy with it for the price (I have tried to solder
components myself in the past, so I take my hat off to these guys).
- Setup. It's pretty easy to set up - basically all it needs to
know are it's IP address, netmask, plus the IP address of the server
and the local gateway. It stores these away too so that you never need
to reenter the information merely because you pulled out the power cord.
- Sound quality. This aspect is great. It seems to output as good
quality a signal as my sound blaster card being fed by a powerful cpu
doing the decoding. Perhaps this is natural given the dedicated
decoding chip, however it's especially impressive given the small size
and power-draw of the machine. Also there are no clicks, buzzes, hums
or delays - just how a hi-fi component should be.
- User Interface. Physically, the display is everything it is
claimed to be. It is legible to me from across the room whilst sat on
the couch. The remote is a little cheap and nasty, but then it is
truly a off-the-shelf item (I could replace it from my local
electronics shop). I find the browser a little spartan so far, but
this is an area of extremely active development (due to the power of
Open Source) so I have every faith that many more features will be
available in due course - way to go guys!
- Looks. Well, my wife doesn't mind it, so that's a start! From the
front it looks cool. From the side it looks a little more unfinished
(chips and leds visible) but actually I like it that way.
- Suggestions. I would like the ability for it to play from m3u
files so that it would play back albums in the correct order. It would
also be nice if it could talk to multiple servers and merge all the
files available. That way my wife can keep her mp3s on her Windows
machine and I can keep mine on my linux server, and yet we can share
the player without reprogramming the IP address. Both of these should
be possible without any hardware changes due to the client-server
architecture where the server is a remote open source perl program (=>
easy to hack) and the client can be software upgraded using the
bootloader - again, very smart design choices in such a modest piece
of hardware.
- Verdict. 9/10. One point docked due to lack of Ogg support. I know
the reasons, but I'm a little tiny bit uncomfortable with the
behaviour of the MP3 patent holders.
Created October 13th 2001
